Philadelphia Movie Review Essay

More than a decade after AIDS was first identified as a disease, "Philadelphia" marks the first time Hollywood has risked a big-budget film on the subject. No points for timeliness here; made-for-TV docudramas and the independent film "Longtime Companion" have already explored the subject, and "Philadelphia" breaks no new dramatic ground. Instead, it relies on the safe formula of the courtroom drama to add suspense and resolution to a story that, by its nature, should have little suspense and only one possible outcome.

Advertisement

And yet "Philadelphia" is quite a good film, on its own terms. And for moviegoers with an antipathy to AIDS but an enthusiasm for stars like Tom Hanks and Denzel Washington, it may help to broaden understanding of the disease. It's a ground-breaker like "Guess Who's Coming to Dinner" (1967), the first major film about an interracial romance; it uses the chemistry of popular stars in a reliable genre to sidestep what looks like controversy.

The story involves Hanks as Andrew Beckett, a skillful lawyer in a big, old-line Philadelphia law firm. We know, although at first the law firm doesn't, that Beckett has AIDS. Visits to the clinic are part of his routine. Charles Wheeler, the senior partner (Jason Robards) hands Beckett a case involving the firm's most important client, and then, a few days later, another lawyer notices on Beckett's forehead the telltale lesions of the skin cancer associated with AIDS.

Beckett is yanked off the case and informed he doesn't have a future with the firm. He suspects he's being fired for being sick.

He's correct. (Wheeler, feeling somehow contaminated by association, barks to an associate, "He brought AIDS into our offices - into our men's room!") Beckett determines to take a stand, and sue the law firm. But his old firm is so powerful that no attorney in Philadelphia wants to take it on, until Beckett finally goes in desperation to Joe Miller (Denzel Washington), one of those lawyers who advertises on TV, promising to save your driver's license.

Miller doesn't like homosexuals, but agrees to take the case, mostly for the money and exposure. And then the story falls into the familiar patterns of a courtroom confrontation, with Mary Steenburgen playing the counsel for the old firm. (Her character has no appetite for what is obviously a fraudulent defense, and whispers "I hate this case!" to a member of her team.) The screenplay by Ron Nyswaner works subtly to avoid the standard cliches of the courtroom. Even as the case is progressing, the film's center of gravity switches from the trial to the progress of Beckett's disease, and we briefly meet his lover (Antonio Banderas) and his family, most especially his mother (Joanne Woodward), whose role is small but supplies two of the most powerful moments in the film. By the time the trial reaches its conclusion, the predictable outcome serves mostly as counterpoint for the movie's real ending.

Advertisement

The film was directed by Jonathan Demme, who with Nyswaner finds original ways to deal with some of the inevitable developments of their story. For example, it's obvious that at some point the scales will fall from the eyes of the Washington character, and he'll realize that his prejudices against homosexuals are wrong; he'll be able to see the Hanks character as a fellow human worthy of affection and respect. Such changes of heart are obligatory (see, for example, Spencer Tracy's acceptance of Sidney Poitier in "Guess Who's Coming to Dinner").

But "Philadelphia" doesn't handle that transitional scene with lame dialogue or soppy extrusions of sincerity. Instead, in a brilliant and original scene, Hanks plays an aria from his favorite opera, one he identifies with in his dying state. Washington isn't an opera fan, but as the music plays and Hanks talks over it, passionately explaining it, Washington undergoes a conversion of the soul. What he sees, finally, is a man who loves life and does not want to leave it. And then the action cuts to Washington's home, late at night, as he stares sleeplessly into the darkness, and we understand what he is feeling.

Scenes like that are not only wonderful, but frustrating, because they suggest what the whole movie could have been like if the filmmakers had taken a leap of faith. But then the film might not have been made at all; the reassuring rhythms of the courtroom drama, I imagine, are what made this material palatable to the executives in charge of signing the checks.

"Philadelphia" is a good movie, and sometimes more than that, and the Hanks performance (which, after all, really exists outside the plot) is one of the best of the year. Sooner or later, Hollywood had to address one of the most important subjects of our time, and with "Philadelphia" the ice has been broken.

In a year or two, it will be time for another film to consider the subject more unblinkingly. This is a righteous first step.

Advertisement

Reveal Commentscomments powered by

Essay/Term paper: Movie - philadelphia

Essay, term paper, research paper:  Movie Reviews

See all college papers and term papers on Movie Reviews

Need a different (custom) essay on Movie Reviews? Buy a custom essay on Movie Reviews

Need a custom research paper on Movie Reviews? Click here to buy a custom term paper.

In the movie Philadelphia a lawyer named Joe

miller takes a heroic journey. His journey is

taking a case dealing with an Aids patience that is

working in a distinguished law firm . Andrew

Beckon is wrongfully accused of losing an

important document regarding an important cort

case. To make the call of this hero more

interesting, he has a personal problem with

homosexual behaver . Also , he has to deal

with society "s mindset on gays. Joe turns

down the call at first, but then receives it after

realizing that, Andrew Beckon has no one

else.











Next, in the hero"s journey Joe goes though the

"jumping off point" of his journey. He is

interfaced between the know, that Andrew

Becker was fired from his job at the law firm.

Also, The unknown why was he fired from a

well-known law firm after being called " One Of

the best", by the head director. Joe Miller is

faced with finding the facts, mainly about why

was this "promising" lawyer without a job? Was

the firing of Andrew Beckon because he was an

active homosexual with Aids? This being one of

the biggest struggles taken by this hero?







Now, In this case Joe faces many challenges.

One: being how people really feel about

homosexuals. The second: proving to the journey

that sex preference does not hold an individual

working ability . The Third challenge, being up

against highly trained layers being accused of

firing aid patience. The forth challenge dealing

with, finding out why Andrew was really fired.







Though the Joe"s whole journey there are two

helpers. One Andrew Beckon himself , is aware

of what other law firms reactions are to aids

patience working for them. The other being Joe"s

wife making him aware of whom in their family

is homosexual. With both of them influencing this

hero, Joe is shown that some things are really are

an important risk.He is just learnig that not

everyone thinks his way( Man and woman).







Now at this point in the movie Philadelphia Joe

ungues the abyss. He is faced with the greatest

challenge of his whole journey. Can he win this

case before Andrew passes on? Also, do

homosexuals really make people more or less of

a person? He cannot take any more challenges

until he looks though himself to find the answers

to defend Andrew.







Joe Miller encounters a drastic change in the way

he thinks and views about homosexuals; after

going though the case. In the beginnings of his

quest Joe is afraid to even touch Andrew. Now

he is like a brother to him, part of the family in a

sense. He now seems to look at homosexuals in a

new light. He sees that your sex preference

doesn"t define you spirit as a person.











Finally, Joe returns to reality, after Andrew"s

death he sees what an impact Andrew has had on

his life, Joe is able to understand the life of a

hard working man. All Andrew wanted to do was

reprsent people in a court of law as best as he

possibly could.



Lastly, Joe understands why people stereotype

but, also why



things that you do in your personal life are

different, than the attitude and ability to work as

an individual." You"re truly a good man" Joe tells

Andrew on his deathbed. In return this is a lot for

Joe to deal with because of his feelings toward

the whole situation. "Thanks for everything "

replies Andrew as Joe is sliding his oxygen mask

up to avoid slipping, Joe learns "not to judge a

book by it"s cover" but what"s inside.

 

Other sample model essays:

Culture / Mozart

Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart was born in Salzburg, Austria on January 27th, 1756. He was born to Leopold and Anna Maria Pertl. Leopol was a very successful composer, voilinist, and...

Culture / Mp3

MP3 Subject: MP3 One of the most exciting and innovative ways to get music these days is not in the mall and not at a huge mega electronic store, it's not even by a mail order...

Culture / Music Analogy

"The final years of the 1970"s saw the emergence of a new style of pop music that would continue in popularity into the early 1980"s. This music was known, by its fans at that time, as New Wa...

Culture / Music And Censorship

Music and Censorship In our society today, some musicians and their music drain and plague the moral and spiritual well-being of the people; therefore, censorship offers a necessary action t...

Culture / Music Censorship

Music and Censorship In our society today, some musicians and their music drain and plague the moral and spiritual well-being of the people; therefore, censorship offers a...

Culture / Music In The United States

With the start of the 20th century music began to play a huge part in the rapidly maturing United States. The music of the 20th century was not only there to entertain the people but it was more. I...

Culture / Nirvana

Nirvana was a band until one of the band members died. He killed himself because he was on to much drugs. His name was Kurt Cobain. He was born on February 20, 1967. He met two other people a...

Culture / Nosferatu

Horror films of today employ several film techniques to invoke responses from the viewer. However, early silent films relied more on these techniques because without a script, the viewer needs ...

Culture / No Sex

Our group chose "Speak To The Hand" by Lakita Garth. This song talks about the health risks of casual sex, and sexual encounters. We chose it because of it"s positive message and the good resu...

Culture / On The Waterfront

Terry Malloy as a "Hero???" When Terry Malloy was first introduced, he did not make any indications that he would strive for the respect that he gained throughout the story. His tough-guy beh...

One thought on “Philadelphia Movie Review Essay

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *